A good name is better than much fine oil.
Ethics of the Fathers Chapter 6 Mishna 7
Donald Trump is promising to make America rich again by using the power of the purse to intimidate our allies. In Trump’s over-simplified universe, all we have to do is intimidate people to get what we want. Since America is an economic and military power-house, it ought to be able to get everything it wants.
But there is another kind of capital that Trump is burning through with record speed–political capital–the good graces of our allies and the respect of our adversaries. For instance, we stand to lose a lot if we alienate Canada. Taking the attitude that Canada is a less rich country and therefore we will simply ignore Canada’s wants and needs, and disregard its interests, is foolhardy. Someday we will need the Canadians; or we will find that we would have been a hell of a lot better off for having their trust and cooperation on some matter of mutual importance. Why tear down this relationship? Trudeau may mollify Trump, but even now the Canadian people have begun to sour on America.
This reckless attitude toward the goodwill of our friends and allies is no different than someone who believes that they have an endless supply of money. Eventually, they end up bankrupt. Trump will burn through American political capital only to find we need something we cannot get simply by throwing our weight around.
Take Columbia–yes, we can throw our economic might in this small, poor country’s face, deciding that we should be able to have all we want simply because we are bigger and might makes right. But why? Why throw away a perfectly good relationship? It is ironic that Trump claims that the flow of drugs into the US is one of his top priorities and then deliberately alienates one of America’s most important allies in stopping the flow of illegal drugs. Sure we are bigger than Columbia, but that doesn’t mean they have nothing to offer us. The diplomatic relationship is still worth a lot. And Columbia knows that. A time will come when we need something from the Columbians that we cannot cajole them into providing. A moment will arise when the political capital we have invested in for years will prove invaluable to the interests of America, and will have a real-world impact on our everyday lives.
It’s almost impossible to make some other country share intelligence. The benefits of a stable economy in a troubled region are something that cannot be obtained by coercion. Aid and democracy efforts keep people from becoming migrants in the first place. Our interests extend beyond our borders.
There are things America needs and wants that bullying cannot afford us. There are more things for which bullying is the really hard way. I’m not asking anybody to be a bleeding heart liberal. Political capital is necessary. It’s about being pragmatic. Just as no one person has an endless supply of money, no one nation can address all of its interests by projecting intimidation.
Progressive Without Apology 