If you take a step back and look in on Trump from the outside, Trump is fundamentally un-American. The things that make America a unique, in some sense exceptional, democracy are the exact opposite of what Trump says and does.
Being an actual American means taking certain things for granted:
Does anybody remember the American revolution? The whole point was no kings. The founding fathers produced a document designed to be as much of a bulwark against tyranny as any document that anybody could possibly come up with. You do what you know they intended (no technicalities), even when you think it’s inconvenient.
You don’t like what the courts tell you, you think it’s unjust. Maybe you’re right. You will be given due process. You will have your day in court, no matter how good or bad you are. You have the right to appeal. Take it all the way to the Supreme Court if you need to. But you don’t have the right to snub your nose at a judge who rules against you. It’s called the law.
What about the idea that it is better to have a criminal go free than to imprison an innocent person. America believes in having human rights in its prisons. We don’t hire dictators to violate people’s human rights as a way to intimidate unaccompanied children who have walked across jungles for a shot at the American dream. We need to have a border and it needs to be illegal to just walk across it. But, they want a better life. If I lived in their countries I might want a better life. Fundamentally, immigration is good. For most of us, our ancestors did it.
The press says things about you you don’t like. There’s the first amendment. It’s a free country. Nobody has the right to slander, but stop whining when people exercise their freedom of speech.
We should be allies with people who want to be our allies and enemies with people who want to be our enemies. The Canadians should like us!? We should attack when provoked, when we need to do so for our own safety. Don’t tread on me. But we should not go into the world senselessly intimidating or starting conflicts with people who want to be our friends. In other words, we don’t start fights, we finish them.
Other people matter. Yes, we don’t always have enough here. But there is always someone worse off than you are. It’s wrong to just not give a shit. When refugees come here you donate something because at least you’ve never had to worry about ending up a refugee. Good people are good no matter how they got here.
There’s no such thing as a self-made man (or woman). If you make it big you give back, you pay your fair share, you are grateful for all the things your nation did for you.
Whatever happened to the well-thought-out, nuanced opinion that seeks to see both sides of the conflict. The opinion that isn’t extreme on either side; the seeking for common sense solutions. So, I deliberately digress. This is my opinion of Trump’s immigration policies.
A truly American response to Trump’s refusal to follow a court order to “turn the planes around if necessary”–people are innocent until proven guilty. The people on that plane did not have their day in court. They are gangsters, you say. They are suspected gangsters. What kind of country would America be if it didn’t give a day in court to everyone suspected of being a gangster? The Philippines maybe. And, no, I won’t just take ICE’s word for it that they will only deport criminals. They actually have a very bad track record for getting law-abiding taxpayers caught up in their dragnets.
I have nuanced attitudes about law-abiding taxpayers with no papers. Yes, on the one hand, we need borders. Just leaving people here undocumented is a band-aid on a broken immigration system. The presence of so many undocumented workers is disrupting the labor market. However, that is often because they are so easily exploited. On the other hand, what Trump is doing makes no sense. First, he needs the military, then says he needs to detain families. Which is it?
In my own life, there are people committing crimes a whole lot worse than not having papers. I wish my government could make these crimes a priority. Some fool stole my trombone out of my storage unit. It was worth next to nothing but had great sentimental value. A few years later, the rear wheel of my bike got stolen. This was approximately $100 to replace–a lot of money, really. Then, sometime later, my apartment building has a laundry room that was open all the time. There is no lock on the outside door. My landlord had problems with homeless people trying to sleep in the laundry room. Now, the door is locked and we have to have a key. In each case, what could my local cops do? Nothing. They don’t have the manpower. Theft is on the rise in my community, so is homelessness and we, like everybody, have an opioid epidemic to deal with. Do I really want my local cops focusing their energy on people whose only real crime is working too hard at jobs other people refuse to do? especially if it makes it harder for them to deal with crimes like theft? No.
As for the Federal government, I have nothing against finding gangsters from other countries and sending them back where they came from. That’s just common sense. But the Feds have a long history of not being able to separate the sheep from the goats. So rather than deporting people who have become an indispensable part of the tax base, they should learn how to conduct an immigration raid where they only catch criminals.
America is losing the things that make America America, and nobody seems to be responding. What people can’t seem to see is that Trump is not just a threat to American democracy, he is a threat to American identity.
Progressive Without Apology 